Wanted to be sure you saw this

Response from MRFF Founder and President Mikey Weinstein
…….read this one, too, brother

BILL DONOHUE’S ABOVE OP-ED (Monday, April 27, ’20)
By: MRFF Advisory Board Member Ted Furlow, Retired Director of Pastoral Planning after 16 years of ministry
in the Catholic Diocese of San Bernardino, CA
When I agreed to join the Advisory Council of the Military Religious Freedom Foundation I realized that I would have to keep connected with their vast daily e-mail stream. As a matter of procedure, I try to tap in once or twice a week to see what is going on. So, I was surprised to read that Bill Donohue, the lead voice of The Catholic League, had weighed in on the argument around the appropriateness and legality of posting religious information on the Command Facebook page at Fort Drum. Condemning MRRF’s position as some form of assault on faith, he was quickly joined by a number of “Catholic”, posting supporting his stand. All well and good, but as an exercise in free speech and free opinions, it is a bit foggy on facts.
I am a cradle Catholic. I was raised in a very traditional Catholic home, benefitting from Catholic education from grade school to high school, to college, and to a Master’s Degree in Pastoral Theology. I am a participating Catholic, a financial supporter of my parish and the school, a member of the pastoral council, and a member of our building and grounds committee. My Catholic life has been impacted by the example of my parents, the Sisters of the Holy Cross, and an exceptionally long run from high school to that Master’s Degree with the Jesuits. In my 75 years in my faith I have learned many things, and my life has been well served by my faith. Mr. Donohue and his Catholic League inhabit the traditionalist wing of the American church, and I do not think of him as particularly relevant to the average Joe and Jane in the pews. While it would be one thing if his intervention were to truly support religious freedom, or even the excess of religious privilege, his screed about Christian faith being removed from Facebook is just a conservative dog whistle to prompt a reaction from his small base and to stimulate donations to support his livelihood.
As a boy I experienced firsthand the discrimination and prejudice towards Catholics in the 1950’s. Some came from ill informed protestants, but much came from Evangelical Christians who were the precursors of today’s conservative right wing evangelicals. As I matured, I was always sensitive to anything that threatened, infringed upon, ridiculed, or abused my free expression of my faith. So, understanding the immense civil influence of government, I support the constitutional separation of church and state – as onerous as it may be at times – to insure the full freedom of my Catholic beliefs. It is the freedom of everyone’s’ religious beliefs to exist outside of the color of government authority, or government influence. I share solidarity with those who support the free expression of religion, but I am diametrically opposed to those who would impose or imply, under any circumstances a specific brand of faith as a standard for all.
MRRF is not telling the chaplains at Ft. Drum that they cannot do their ministry; they are telling them that they cannot make their ministry a benchmark for the 10th Mountain Division. They should evangelize in the chapel and on their own Chaplain’s Facebook pages, and not advertise salvation on the Command pages.
The most effective Gospel is not always the one that is preached. It is best when it is modeled by the life of those who proclaim it.

Lot of political talking points in it.  Also as a “practicing” Catholic I’m unsure what participating Catholic means so I don’t know if this person is true to the teaching of Christ or simply paying lip service.  Dismissing Bill Donohue of the Catholic League without really addressing his argument is simply an attack to get people to kill the messenger so to speak.  And if you disagree with him, whom I have found to be an orthodox Catholic, then you very well may not be orthodox in your faith.  Every “practicing” Catholic I know has nothing but respect and love for Bill.   He’s actually on of my favorites.
That having been said, I simply don’t know who your source is and don’t know how trustworthy.
I would like to end by saying that I have truly appreciated your efforts at civil discourse and presenting the facts/arguments as you understand them to be.  I don’t agree with you on the matter at hand but still come away enlightened and encouraged.  Thank you.
If you’d like the final word I won’t rebut
     Thanks again and God bless you,
(name withheld)

Share this page:

Commenter Account Access

  • Register for a commenter account
    (Not required to post comments, but will save you time if you're a regular commenter)
  • Log in using your existing account
  • Click here to edit your profile and change your password
  • All comments are subject to our Terms of Use


  1. Infidel

    The Vatican is the great whore of Babylon and every Catholic church is their little prostitutes of false doctrine and the Pope is their false prophet.

  2. Old_ColdWar_MP

    I respectfully ask that you consider refraining from denigrating the faith of another. I do understand, and perhaps even share, in a common skepticism (paired with anger sometimes), regarding even the concept of and individual’s “faith”. But I also, truly believe, that we are all enabled with the human right – to believe in things that others may not – even if we (or they) are wrong.
    And if/when we may find ourselves wrong, then we each should be granted the opportunity to ask those we’ve wronged for forgiveness. And for the sake of humanity, those transgressed upon should find and offer a position of forgiveness.
    I also, and quite frequently, take offense toward the many “opportunists” who have leveraged the faith of an individual (likewise, a community of like minded people), but I’ve found that questioning, even to the point of interrogation, has proven to be a much more fruitful path to follow, than a strike with a “rod” (albeit a written or spoken one).

  3. G

    Yeah Infidel and you have a lot of pastors who act like false prophet.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *